Saturday, May 21, 2011

Belated vindication for Vivien Harrison?

Vivien Harrison died April just gone, never having been 'deframed' from the travesty of injustice imposed on her. She was 'identified' by the Prosecutor (later Judge) David Morris as the mystery woman who fed the baby Rochelle Crewe after her parents Jeanette and Harvey had been murdered. David Morris had driven the spectre of this lie into the reputation of, as she was then Vivien Thomas, to ensure that her then husband Arthur would be convicted of the murders. David Morris did this despite information on the case file that another person, later to be the wife of Len Demler father of Jeanette, Norma had been identified as the woman seen on the property in the days before the discovery of the bodies.

Much of this information is contained in a North and South article by Chris Bird and as much as it vindicates the late Vivien and Arthur Thomas it incriminates the complicity of Police in wilfully exercising a Miscarriage of Justice. However, more than that it shows that the strongest circumstantial evidence available to the police to have enabled a conviction was that against Len Demler. He, like his 2nd wife Norma, fudged and prevaricated that Norma was 'on the scene' that is in Pukekawa around the time of the murders. The police had a positive identification from Bruce Roddick who despite immense pressure was unwavering in his evidence that the woman he was on the Crewe's farm in the days after the murder was not Vivien but indeed was Norma Demler, the later information was never put before a jury as was also excluded the note in Detective Len Johnson's work-diary '..that Roddick was going to identify the woman he saw as Mrs Demler,'concluded with the further entry 'confirms our suspicions re identification.'

Of course if the allegation of Morris was negated, and the proof positive revealed that Mr Roddick had identified Norma Demler the case against Arthur was shot, as were the obscene allegations against Vivien. Moreover, a complete case was built against the true perpetrator of the crime Len Demler. I say the true perpetrator because there was no reason for Len Demler to lie about when he met Norma Demler or when she was 'on the scene' cooking for the shearers. All of this is substantiated by various people including even members of the extended Demler family. What becomes revealed is that among the police was evidence and belief that Norma had fed the baby and that therefore her husband to be was implicated in the murders.

Birt's article shows the role Norma Demler soon began to assume in the affairs of the trust which own the various farming properties associated to Len and his family even though Colin Harvey, a trustee said of her involvement 'She had no right to be there (at the meetings of the trust) as she was not a trustee and she did all the talking.'

Even the unshakable recollections of Bruce Roddick as to the identity of the mystery woman would sought to undermined by another Detective Mike Charles who considered that it was important to determine what the sexual inclinations of the late Bruce Roddick were, as though anyone could imagine the relevance of that an issue as the reliability of Bruce's identification of Norma and 'failure' to identify the favourite of Prosecutor Morris - Vivien.

The Crewe case remains a rare, if yet still raw, blight on the landscape of Justice in New Zealand, and rarer still for the now public knowledge that while one man was prosecuted members of the Police believed it was another man 'courted' and cultivated into a role of innocence that some within the Police believed was guilty and who was never thoroughly investigated and became unwatched under the blind eye of Justice that seeks a result no matter the cost and the issues of right or wrong or of basic fairness and Justice.

Chris Birt's article is a must read for those interested in or affected by this case, and reveals other startling information that the the Commissioner of the time, Walton, instructed Auckland Police (at a point after the convictions) to not formally interview Norma Demler. At work from the very top down was activity to lay open shortcomings in the original investigation, Walton told Chris Birt that if he should see the officer involved again to 'ask him what the reason was.' Another startling demonstration of self-protection by a request to ask the officer receiving the order what the reason was for Walton to have made the order.

Friday, May 20, 2011

Naughty, naughty Cybernana look what she's

doing now....

Yet another 7th of May has come and gone. Still no sight of Milton's book. It was to be published 7th May 2010, then 7th May 2011. Perhaps he is still trying to find a glass lens in the photos.

Quote
cybernana (596 ) 8:20 pm, Fri 20 May #32167


I'm not sure but I think she's teasing the old twisted sisters, who having lost on every count, were sure dear Milton was going to save the day - with an impressive book explaining how daddy's blood got sucked into the rifle barrel, and how his hands got all cut, bruised and covered with blood when he forgot to make the porridge and go to the toilet.

Nana's these days, they're so naughty.

Tuesday, May 17, 2011

Robert van Driek (skylab) what a spacer...

This from the moron...

is a joke. Joe Karam says, David has never been invited to speak anywhere in New Zealand about his experience off being unjustly found guilty of murdering his whole family. Joe also says, the media would eat him up for breakfast. WELL WHAT DO YOU EXPECT JOE, HES FARKING GUILTY!! I wonder what David thinks whilst sitting next to the Hurricane, a truly innocent man. Could David actually look him in the eye?

Edited by skylab6 at 6:33 pm, Tue 17 May

Quote
skylab6 (158 ) 6:33 pm, Tue 17 May #1


He's wondering what people think, and he's confirming full idiocy and introspection difficulties by not realising that David was found not guilty. What a dickhead you are robert the dickhead.

Sunday, May 15, 2011

Dear twisted sisters, what would happen if you were a director of a company

that ran a message board on which people posted deliberate lies? Would you not be responsible, even after being told what was on your boards. In Aussie they said yes you would be responsible...

ACCC v Allergy Pathway Pty Ltd and Anor (No 2) [2011] FCA 74
22nd March 2011


A recent case in the Federal Court which held a company responsible for claims made in testimonials that its clients posted on its Facebook wall.

print friendlyemail a friendrelated publicationsrelated servicesBackground

In 2009 the ACCC had brought an action alleging that Allergy Pathway had engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct, falsely represented goods or services were of a particular standard or quality and represented that its services had benefits which they do not have by making certain statements about its allergy services in marketing brochures and a variety of other publications. The respondents didn’t contest these allegations and, to avoid permanent injunctions, offered up undertakings to the Court committing to refrain from “making or publishing or causing to be made or published in any internet website, radio, television or newspaper advertisements or brochures or other written promotional material” statements representing that:

it could accurately test for and identify an allergen for a person;
it could cure or eliminate or successfully treat any allergy or allergic reaction;
its treatments were safe or low risk; or
after its treatments it would be safe for a person to have contact with the allergen to which the person had an allergic reaction.
The undertakings were given by the company and by the sole director of the company, who was taken to have been “involved” in the contraventions.

Allegations

The ACCC in these proceedings alleged that the respondents were in contempt because they had breached the undertakings by making several categories of objectionable publications, including in:

testimonials written by clients and posted by Allergy Pathway on its website, on its Facebook wall and on its Twitter page; and
testimonials written and posted by clients on Allergy Pathway’s Facebook wall.
The question

The respondents conceded that statements and links to statements which the company itself posted breached the undertakings. The Court had to determine whether Allergy Pathway and its director were similarly in contempt for allowing misleading statements posted by independent individuals on the company’s Facebook wall or Twitter page to remain there after the company became aware of the comments.

The respondents had said that the breaches were not deliberate, and that they thought they would not breach the undertakings by publishing the views of Allergy Pathways’ clients provided that they removed extravagant claims or words. However, they accepted that their approach to moderating their Facebook fans’ and Twitter followers’ testimonials was insufficient.

The finding

Finkelstein J held that the company and its director were in contempt because of these Facebook and Twitter statements. Key factors in the determination were that Allergy Pathways knew the statements had been posted on its Facebook wall / Twitter page and took no steps to remove them and if Allergy Pathways had made the statements itself it would have been in breach of the undertakings.

Finkelstein J said:

“While it cannot be said that Allergy Pathway was responsible for the initial publication of the testimonials (the original publisher was the third party who posted the testimonials on Allergy Pathway’s Twitter and Facebook pages) it is appropriate to conclude that Allergy Pathway accepted responsibility for the publications when it knew of the publications and decided not to remove them. Hence it became the publisher of the testimonials. In any event it is clear that it caused them to continue to be published from the time it became aware of their existence, which is enough to put Allergy Pathway in breach of the second limb of its undertaking [i.e. causing to be made or published].”
Each respondent was fined $7,500. Injunctions for 3 years were made and the court made declarations of breach, corrective advertising and costs.


This looks bad news for the very twisted sisters. Who would have thought that if you controlled a message board and you let people like Fox, Kennard, Stockdale, Taylor and others to lie their rotten heads off to harass and stalk people - the Courts would hold you responsible along with the direct harassers? Certainly not Trade Me, well maybe not until now.

Saturday, May 14, 2011

The twisted sisters day in Court has been put off

as many readers may know. Having had a few inquiries over the last few days I can confirm a hearing is scheduled the week after next on a point of law. But that concerns Trade Me and an issue of essentially who is responsible for what is published on a board. I have named a director of the host company who believe himself not to be responsible much in the way a director is absolved from debt in most situations where a limited liability company flounders because of debt and debtors are unable under law to pursue company directors in the normal matter of course.

I see a distinction whereby the limits of Limited Liability for a company under the law are restricted wholly (as far as I know)to debt but not necessarily to civil or criminal offending. Trade Me have rules which they 'hope' more than they can be certain of, which indemnify themselves against civil law of publishing. In the first instance I think that fails, but more particularly where the published material has been defamatory and intended to frighten, intimidate or harass members of the public (but which TM have published anyway) I think any 'limits' are a long way out the door. The law wasn't designed to accommodate across the board offending and is specific in terms of debt liability limited to a company and not the directors. The issues raised however by the publications TM have published on their boards cross into new territory not considered in Limited liability legislation where offending or trespass has transgressed other law.

I've had a few weeks away from the paperwork but on returning it still seems perfectly clear that TM are a traditional publisher and liable for defamatory comment that may be published and more importantly, in this case, for threats and stalking on the boards by TM members.

I haven't mentioned the 3 sisters to this point because they're irrelevant to the legal argument and not a party to the consideration of the law on the matter. They will not be represented at the interim hearing and have no been invited or instructed to do so because their position is irrelevant to the question of law. Additionally to that TM have raised no argument defending the actions of the 3 sister bros which entitles a position that TM accept (unfortunately for the 3 wise ones) the harassment took place. More interesting is that 2 of the 3 stalking heroes wrote incriminating letters to the Court, a couple of which revealed more stalking than I had been aware of - of course that matter isn't over yet, being reserved in the meantime but it's apparent they don't have a show, to the point they have indicated they won't even turn up at Court when the matter against them is convened for final lawful determination.

Overall, the news is not good for the twisted sisters already named in these proceedings and elsewhere, nor for the others excluded from this first test of the law but not forgotten by any stretch of the imagination. The laws they broke in their persecution and spreading of hate will be the same laws they will be tested against and the world will be a better place for it.

Johnson and Knight - false imprisonment.

More on this subject, the recent Sunday night show on this bleak episode of NZ Justice recorded a number of the reasons why the men were compensated. This included video footage of them in a service station at a time which precluded them from having started the fire, that alone shows the corruption of this case and the reveals the number of people who 'look away' from anything disturbing about the nature of the now quashed convictions. Additionally, it was a revealed there was a matter which was being kept confidential that also 'proved' the men's innocence.

Some will recall that the two mothers in this case researched recent arson records for the Foxton area and other relevant information as part of their crusade to have their sons set free. Why there should need to be anything kept secret (and probably an agreement forced upon the young men - if they wanted to be compensated)just adds to concerns that there has been a 'sell off' of some discription - a deal done to prevent the men speaking out on some information they might have. A situation of this nature doesn't restore any confidence, even when putting aside the fact that the OIC of the case remains in the police fold.

I will remind others that when Jaden Knight was standing on the steps of Parliament having received an 'apology' from Simon Power, the poster boy of the Sensible Sentencing Trust and the author of draconian statutes that have 'refined' some of our laws back to the dark ages, he spoke of feeling like being 'bullied' again. What bullying could have happened during the progress of his apology and compensation other than 'having' to agree to not speak out on some matters relevant to the case?

Well, I have two. Either that somebody else has been convicted, charged or admitted in some way responsibility for the Foxton arson. I could be completely wrong, but that is the difficulty when a Government try to extract themselves from a Miscarriage of Justice without full disclosure. Simon Power, who probably cooked his own goose (and hence his surprise announcement of retiring from politics) because of his unhealthy association with Garth McVicar, David Garrett and other crooks who manipulated the public (and John Key) it seems with morbid pleas to the vulnerable by heightening fear - is now seen as the Minister who apologised for matters which were of public record but refusing to do so over matters, necessarily made 'secret' and to be kept from the public.

I'd like to see Jaden Knight or one of the mothers speak out on what 'can't' be disclosed and to hell with the secret agreement. This secret agreement has all the hallmarks of the 2 men being bullied into silence (remember one of them, Johnston - didn't even bother attending Parliament to met the the 'glorious' Minister.) Then we would see if the Government had the temerity to try to enforce their 'insistance' (contract) of silence, that would be another court case against the odds (and fairness and Justice) that the 2 men would win.

Wednesday, May 11, 2011

The false imprisonment of Jaden Knight and Phillip Johnston.

Much to reflect upon with this case. In some ways deciding where the place to start is as difficult to arrive at as where the finish might be. I wonder what the touch stone might be, and realise that it is 2 mothers. There is a recognised concept that the wheels of justice turn very slowly, that justice is in many ways inert and selfish, that justice has become a law to itself, a preservation of itself over the faults that often make it blind, unable to speak, hear or see.

So if our Minister of Justice takes many years to speak out, apologise over a case that has found its root cause in Police misconduct years ago, then why haven't the Courts spoken sooner, why do they not speak now - in this time when again victims of miscarriages of justice and their families call for the formation of a separate entity to investigate cases such as that of the Foxton arson because of which these 2 men were wrongfully imprisoned - why are the Courts silent? The Courts must see more clearly that members of the public or lay people the mechanics, lies, and fabrications of MOJ but they leave them for the victims to pick a way through an unforgiving an forbiding Justice system that is onerous in it's design.

We all know a Judge can gaol a defendant, a lawyer, a member of the public in a Court room for 'insolence,' swearing, the clothing the wear, for being upset, shouting or cursing - so clearly they can gaol a police officer for contempt when he is giving evidence and clearly lying, or can note on the public record his observations of circumstances that have led an innocent person to Court and imprisoned or charge for an offence on evidence that is false. Unfortunately, the more I think about the role of the Courts in the role of imprisonment it appears equally as unsatisfactory to that of police officers, scientists, or lying witnesses play a role no less than a Judge or panel of Judges who remain unmoved, or unwilling to speak on events, such as the false imprisonment of these 2 men, when it passes before them.

If I'm offended that the OIC that fitted up these 2 men remains in the Police, has never been charged with any crime relating to the MOJ, then why aren't the Courts when the case passes before them? There are no expedients in Justice, only raw, uncompromising truth, the failure of truth in a prosecution is the failure of the entire case - not an opportunity to look for supporting facts elsewhere in a already blemished prosecution. The investigation into these unfortunate men in the overall wash up took minutes, hours, days but unravelling their nightmare has taken years - observed either without concern for the interests of justice and the safety or citizens. Time for the Courts to speak up, not to 'excuse' logic, or 'unfortunate' breaches of investigating and prosecution procedure. Time for the Courts to speak the public mind, to be active when things go wrong and not appear lethargic and system-protecting.

If the Courts don't speak who else will, campaigners such as Joe Karam, Pat Booth, Dr Sprott? (and respect to many others of their kind.) Women such as these two mothers and the mother of Aaron Farmer, who will protest for these good people who, for whatever reason have been disturbed enough over a MOJ to step out from themselves, from their life into the mouth of an indolent beast. Where is the life in our Courts in the people considered to be insightful, sharp, worthy and humble administrators of the truth, make no comment or order when a broken family pass by trying to rescue a son or daughter from a sleeping beast? It isn't right.

To finish on this subject, I wonder why the families needed to go to Parliament to accept their 'apology' when in fact that it is the lawmakers who should be cap in hands, or with fine mats hiding their shame at the door of their victims.